Cayey Homes for Sale

Cayey Homes for Sale

Welcome to Cayey, Puerto Rico – a charming town nestled in the heart of the island, known for its lush landscapes, vibrant culture, and warm community spirit. Often referred to as "La Ciudad de los Reyes" (The City of Kings), Cayey boasts a rich history and stunning natural beauty, making it an ideal place to call home.

Cayey is surrounded by the majestic mountains of the central region, providing breathtaking views and a plethora of outdoor activities. Whether you enjoy hiking through the beautiful trails of the nearby Toro Negro Forest or exploring the local parks, there’s no shortage of ways to immerse yourself in nature. The town itself is a hub of cultural vibrancy, featuring delightful local eateries, artisan shops, and lively festivals that celebrate the island’s heritage.

For those considering a move to this picturesque locale, we have an exciting selection of homes for sale in Cayey. From charming single-family residences to modern townhouses, there's something to suit every lifestyle and budget. Many properties offer spacious backyards, perfect for family gatherings or quiet evenings under the stars. With a growing real estate market, investing in a home in Cayey not only provides a comfortable living space but also a chance to be part of a welcoming community.

Explore the beauty of Cayey and discover your dream home today. With its unique blend of tranquility and culture, this enchanting town is ready to welcome you with open arms. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to make Cayey your new home!

Newest Cayey Homes for Sale

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Bo Sumido Carretera 7737 Km 1 6 Cayey Puerto Rico SubDv.

Luxury Off-Grid Mountain Retreat | Cayey, Puerto Rico Nestled in the peaceful and highly sought-after Barrio Sumido, bordering Barrio Jajome, this exceptional mountain retreat is surrounded by lush greenery, fresh air, and breathtaking panoramic views, offering the perfect balance of privacy, serenity, and modern luxury. Set on 4 cuerdas of land (approximately 3.89 acres or 169,576 square feet), This move-in ready, fully furnished residence offers 1,100 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, featuring one spacious bedroom, one elegant bathroom, and an open-concept layout that embraces the surrounding mountain landscape. Its versatile floor plan also provides excellent potential for future expansion or customization. Engineered for complete energy independence, the property is powered by a premium off-grid solar system featuring 20 solar panels, three 48 kWh batteries, and a 12kW Fortress energy system, providing reliable, self-sufficient power without relying on the electrical grid. Two solar-powered security poles equipped with surveillance cameras further enhance security and convenience. Whether you're seeking a luxury mountain retreat, a high-performing short-term rental investment, or a peaceful retirement residence, this one-of-a-kind property delivers an exceptional lifestyle where contemporary design, sustainability, and nature come together in one of Cayey's most scenic and tranquil settings.

Bo Sumido 7737 Km 1 6, Cayey

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Guavate SubDv.

AT THE TOP OF THE WORLD | GUAVATE MOUNTAIN RETREAT Set at the crown of a mountaintop in Guavate, Cayey, this peaceful refuge feels suspended above the landscape, with sweeping views of the surrounding mountains in every direction. A small winding road leads past a few neighboring residences to the property gate; from there, the path continues upward until the home reveals itself at what feels like the top of the world. The architecture has a tropical modernist undertone, with exposed concrete, practical lines, and wide outdoor spaces designed to let the landscape take center stage. The main residence opens to a generous wraparound veranda and expansive terrace with a pool table and bar area, all oriented toward the views. Inside, the ground level features a dramatic foyer with tall ceilings, an open kitchen, and living and dining areas that flow directly to the terrace, anchored by a working chimney! A rare and atmospheric feature in Puerto Rico, especially meaningful in the cooler mountain months of Cayey. Two bedrooms share a full bathroom on this level, while the entire second floor is dedicated to the primary suite, complete with an oversized walk-in closet, ensuite bathroom, and private covered balcony overlooking the landscape. Surrounded by blooming robles nativos with their lilac-pink flowers, towering red torch ginger, giant ferns and layered tropical foliage, the property feels both elemental and transportive, a place where mountain air and endless green meet in perfect balance. A round dipping pool is perfectly positioned to capture the views, while a separate guest cabaña offers two independent suites, each with their own kitchen and bathroom, separated by a lock-off door for flexibility and privacy. The property is fully supported by a whole-property backup generator and its own private water source with cistern and pump system, an exceptional advantage in today’s climate of water rationing and drought. Private, resilient, and deeply connected to the mountain landscape, this Guavate mountain retreat feels worlds away while remaining unmistakably Puerto Rico.

PR-184 Guavate, Cayey

13 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ Bo Toita Carr 171 Cayey SubDv.

Majestic three-level residence located in the mountains of Cayey, offering extraordinary panoramic 180-degree views and a cool climate year-round. Situated on 4.80 acres of irregular topography and encompassing approximately 10,243 sq. ft. of construction, this residence was thoughtfully designed to accommodate large-scale living and entertaining. The layout features 13 spacious bedrooms, several with double walk-in closets, and two bathrooms on each level, providing functionality, comfort, and privacy throughout the home. This combination creates an ideal setting for a luxury residence, retreat concept, or boutique hospitality development. The property includes two fully functional kitchens: a main kitchen on the third level with mountain views, and a secondary catering-style kitchen on the first level, suitable for private events, culinary operations, or independent use. Additional features, includes a double garage and parking capacity for approximately 10+ vehicles. It also offers two separate entrances, enhancing privacy and functional separation between levels, which supports multiple-use configurations. Located on a quiet local street without controlled access, offering a strong sense of privacy and exclusivity while remaining easily accessible. From its boutique hotel-style entrance to its scale and architectural presence, this residence represents a rare opportunity for buyers seeking a unique property with long-term flexibility and potential. IDEAL FOR: Luxury multigenerational residence Boutique hospitality, guest house, or retreat use High-end investment property with income potential Large-scale private estate living

CARR 171 Mogote, Cayey

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Bo Buena Vista SubDv.

Residence located in an accessible area, up the road from Colmado Colón, approximately 5 minutes from downtown Cayey and the town square. The property features 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, living and dining areas, kitchen, family room, additional sitting area, balcony, and laundry area. The property includes an additional structure at the rear that requires demolition; therefore, it does not qualify for housing assistance programs. The property is only eligible for FHA 203(k) financing. Don’t miss this opportunity!

Daniel Bonilla 30 Buena Vista, Cayey

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Rd15 Km20.6 Bo.Quebrada Arriba SubDv.

Private Mountaintop Retreat in Cayey – 5 Acres with Panoramic Views Perched at approximately 1,000 meters in the central mountains of Puerto Rico, this exceptional 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom retreat sits on 5 acres of lush land, offering 120° horizon views, unmatched privacy, and an adventurous countryside lifestyle unlike any other. Accessed through a long private driveway and surrounded by nature, the property is designed for those who value freedom, outdoor living, and the tranquility of mountain life while still enjoying modern comforts. Only 10 minutes from downtown Cayey and minutes from Guavate’s renowned local culture and cuisine, this estate blends convenience with a true escape into nature. Whether it’s riding 4-wheelers through the property, caring for the animals, harvesting tropical fruit, or enjoying cool mountain air, this home offers a unique lifestyle experience ideal for outdoor enthusiasts seeking both comfort and privacy. Built for reliable full time living or remote work, the property includes Starlink high speed internet, a 10 kilowatt solar system with battery backup powering essential circuits, a gas generator, solar water heater, 600-amp main panel, reverse osmosis water filtration system, a 1,200-gallon stainless steel cistern, and a drilled 300-foot well. The interior features travertine and ceramic tile floors, PVC and quartz finishes, a spacious upstairs primary suite with custom desk and AC, and a living room also equipped with AC. The home additionally includes a gas stove, wraparound porch, security camera system, and a 1-car garage with extensive built-in shelving. Outdoor amenities include a pond, a shed with electricity and water, and licensed potential to build an additional home on the property. The grounds are rich with tropical fruit trees including tangerine, banana, guava, avocado, orange, and pana trees, along with 3 female goats that help naturally maintain the land. Offering cooler mountain temperatures, total privacy, modern infrastructure, and an authentic countryside lifestyle, this one of a kind retreat is ideal as a private residence, vacation home, or investment opportunity. Experience the beauty, adventure, and serenity of Puerto Rico’s mountains while remaining conveniently close to the city

RD15 KM20.6 Bo. Quebrada Arriba, Cayey

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Jajome Alto SubDv.

Infinity pool with panoramic mountain views, this rare retreat blends luxury with nature. Nestled within 41.6 acres (31.92 acres on the main lot and 9.7 acres on two adjacent lots) of lush greenery this exquisite country estate it is a seamless harmony of nature and design. A grand stone staircase, carved into the mountainside, leads you into a home where every detail is crafted to embrace the stunning surroundings. With three bedrooms and three and a half bathrooms, the home offers both comfort and style. Expansive windows frame panoramic views, while smart-home features—including a solar power system and Sonos sound throughout—bring effortless convenience. A built-in wine cellar ensures your favorite vintages are always at hand. The master suite offers a private cinematic experience with a state-of-the-art movie theater setup—perfect for cozy nights in. Step outside to experience the magic of the outdoors: an infinity pool where the trees feel like part of the landscape, a terrace with a fireplace and grill for unforgettable gatherings, and a recently built wooden deck immersed in the forest, perfect for quiet moments in nature. Enjoy reliability with a solar power system consisting of 24 - 440W panels and 2 Tesla Powerwall II batteries. A true sanctuary where luxury meets the wild beauty of the mountains—redefining country living.

km 16.5 Pr-15, Cayey

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Guavate SubDv.

Beautiful property in Guavate, Cayey, offering cool mountain weather, nature views, and a 1,482 m² lot. The home features two concrete housing units, each with its own electric meter, perfect for living in one unit and renting the other, or as an investment. The main home offers 2,921 sq ft, 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a 2-car garage, excellent roof condition, and a balcony with stunning views. The second unit has 1,500 sq ft, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and a private entrance. Includes perimeter fencing, open terrace, and large storage area. Great location near PR-184 with easy access to PR-52.

PR-184 KM 32.4 S Beatriz, Cayey

Start Your Search