Anna Maria Island Homes for Sale

Our website features the best Anna Maria Island Custom Home search, you'll also locate, condos, land and foreclosure properties available in the Anna Maria Island area. Search Florida Custom Homes throughout the State of Florida. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

Anna Maria Island Homes for Sale

$1,799,500
3 Beds 2 Baths Gulf View Sub SubDv.
Welcome to your slice of paradise and coastal retreat! Nestled on a generous corner lot, this beach bungalow residence epitomizes the allure of coastal living, offering unparalleled proximity to the pristine shores of Anna Maria Island Beach and the Gulf of Mexico. Boasting a strategic location on one of the island's most sought-after streets, this expansive property presents a crafted 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom bungalow mere steps away from the renowned Anna Maria Island Beach. Whether you're seeking a permanent residence or an income-generating investment, this adaptable home delivers on both fronts, inviting you to indulge in the peaceful and low-key island lifestyle. Fully furnished to capitalize on immediate income potential, this residence features a bright, airy floor plan designed for effortless living and entertaining. From the welcoming living room to the sunlit dining area and the inviting Florida room, every space carries a sense of coastal charm and relaxation. Laundry facilities, a screened porch, and a sprawling backyard complete with an outdoor shower further enhance the appeal of this seaside retreat. The outdoor oasis is a sanctuary for relaxation and entertainment, offering shade from majestic trees and ample space for gatherings under the Florida sun. Meanwhile, the updated kitchen beckons with its stainless steel appliances, shaker-style cabinets, and butcher block countertops, catering to the needs of both aspiring chefs and casual entertainers alike. Retreat to the master bedroom, where an en-suite bathroom with double sinks awaits, providing the ultimate comfort and convenience. With NO RENTAL RESTRICTIONS, this property presents an exceptional INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY for an INCOME PRODUCING RENTAL, allowing you to capitalize on the thriving vacation rental market of Anna Maria Island. Conveniently located just 2 miles from the exclusive Key Royale Club and within easy reach of many dining options, this home offers the perfect blend of luxury and convenience. Whether you're seeking a personal haven or a lucrative rental property, 120 Maple Ave promises a lifestyle of coastal sophistication and multiple possibilities. Do not miss your chance to make this beachside retreat your own!

120 Maple Avenue, Anna Maria

$3,949,000
5 Beds 3.5 Baths Anna Maria Beach SubDv.
Located WEST of Gulf Drive and ONLY 2 homes from the Gulf of Mexico beaches!!!! This 5 bedroom, 3.5 bathroom home is located on one of the most beautiful streets on Anna Maria island. What makes the home even more unique is 3 spectacular banyan trees that provide gorgeous street appeal and all-day shade, keeps the house cool with no blaring afternoon sun. If you are interested in more bedrooms, it could be easily be transformed into a 6 bed room 5 full bath home with more than 3600 square feet. The home sits among 10 million to more than 20-million-dollar homes and is steps from the Gulf of Mexico. Climb the grand staircase to the main living floor and enter the dining room, great room, and gourmet kitchen area. This home offers an open floor plan with built-ins, a gas fireplace, and an underground gas tank. Pocket sliders that open up to a 20X40 foot screened in porch with Trex flooring, perfect for afternoon cocktails with a gulf breeze! All windows, sliders, and doors are impact hurricane-rated. A private office, half bath, and second master ensuite with a third full bath shared by a family suite also on the main living floor. An elevator, home security system, crown molding throughout, outdoor lighting and beautiful wood floors are more fabulous features. The master bedroom, bath, and closet along with the 5th bedroom, presently used as a second office, create a huge private master suite on the entire top floor. The master closet is as big as a bedroom, as is the master bath! This home was built by Whitehead & Bruce Williams, everything very well thought out and much attention to detail! Walk right out your door, past 2 houses to the sugar sand beaches of world-famous Anna Maria Island. Enjoy watching dolphins, manatees, and gorgeous sunsets with unobstructed sweeping panoramic Gulf views, swim, kayak, paddle board, and float in the warm, clear turquoise waters of the Gulf of Mexico. Walking distance to restaurants and all that Pine Avenue has to offer. Create a lifetime of memories. Don’t wait, come live the dream! Public boat ramps, parks, tennis and basketball courts, a dog park, and a skate park are all available on the Island. There are fitness centers & a "members only" 9-hole Golf Course available. And of course, the 7 miles of AMI BEACHES! Banyan tree shade keeps electric bills very reasonable, even in the summer. An oversized garage to store all your toys for the beach with room for the golf cart as well as your cars. An idea suggested for the large room ground level is to create a workout room on the ground level. A well is on this property currently shared by the rear neighbor, each owns their own pump which serves the irrigation needs. If you want a bigger home, adding a 6th bedroom and 5th full bathroom, please see 2 drawings of proposed changes in attachments. Make your Island dreams a reality and schedule your private showing today.

106 Beach Avenue, Anna Maria

$5,150,000
3 Beds 3.5 Baths Anna Maria Beach SubDv.
Welcome to this stunning show stopping property on the North End of Anna Maria Island!  This is a 3 bedroom + office/den, 3.5 bathrooms and 3,548 sq ft. home featuring views from every enormous window of the Tampa Bay, Sunshine skyway bridge and the City Pier! This luxurious and meticulously designed property offers an unparalleled living experience, seamlessly blending modern amenities with breathtaking views.  Award winning home designed by renowned architectural firm, Halflants + Pichette, they feature very unique finishes including shell stone throughout the home, fully automated smart home, security system, automated shades, temperature, light and A/V controls and more!   As you walk through the open floor plan, you’ll notice the spacious layout, natural light and comfort the home brings.  All 3 bedrooms have their own ensuite bathroom for your convenience and privacy.  Additionally, there’s a versatile office room that could be turned into a fourth bedroom.   The primary bedroom has gorgeous views of the Tampa Bay and City Pier, Lutron shades, large closets as well as a 5ft wide shoe closet!  Ascend to the rooftop retreat where the views get even better!  1,000 sq ft roof top deck includes a stainless steel jacuzzi, full outdoor kitchen, speakers, IPE decking and loungers to soak up the sun.  There is a 3-car garage and an elevator that goes to all 3 levels.  Take a dip in the sparkling heated pool that is elevated with a pool window or relax in the adjacent decks surrounded by lush landscaping and low maintenance artificial turf.  Conveniently located a block away from Pine Avenue and all it has to offer including restaurants, boutiques, ice cream shops and more! Don’t miss this wonderful opportunity and schedule your private showing today!

115 N Bay Boulevard, Anna Maria

$6,195,000
4 Beds 4.5 Baths Luana Isles SubDv.
Under Construction. Stunning, new construction home with 4 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms located on the exclusive Bean Point area of Anna Maria Island. This unique, oversized lot sits at the end of a quiet cul de sac and opens onto a wide waterway. The waterfront home is situated to take advantage of sunsets from every room. The open floor plan flows seamlessly to a large deck overlooking the pool and waterway giving you an exceptional indoor/outdoor living feel. The chef’s kitchen is a dream and includes high-end, built-in Thermador appliances, gorgeous custom cabinetry, quartz counter tops and a walk-in pantry. Entertain at your full service bar featuring a beverage and a wine fridge. Completing the main living level is a private office/den. There are 2 oversized master suites with walk in closets, exquisite bathrooms and sliding glass doors opening to expansive decks. The additional 2 large en suite bedrooms also have incredible views. Other features include a Sonos sound system, large 2 car garage, separate garage to keep your water toys with additional laundry, elevator and more. The backyard oasis may be your favorite as there is a full outdoor covered kitchen and living area with quartz counter tops, grill, stove top, sink, ice maker, beverage fridge, fire table and outdoor shower. A large TV completes the outdoor entertaining space. Enjoy your sleek, resort style heated pool with Baja entry and covered spa. For the fishermen, there is a large dock to store your boat or fish off the dock. It is just a short stroll to the shops and restaurants of Pine Ave and the world-renowned beaches of Anna Maria. Offered turnkey furnished by a professional designer with all of the high-end amenities and furnishings you would expect in this luxury property. Dock your boat and make this piece of Anna Maria Island paradise your own!

111 Gull Drive, Anna Maria

$1,650,000
Island Cedars SubDv.
Great property located on the north end of Anna Maria Island. This property has two side of water (small canal on the west side) offering privacy yet so close to all the fun amenities on Pine Ave. With over 81 feet of frontage on Lake Marsha this lot would make an amazing build site for a custom beach house on AMI or use it stands, a cute 3 bed 3 bath cottage reminiscent of old Anna Maria. This property is nestled within Anna Maria Island's coveted "North End" and only 2 houses away from the bustling shops and exquisite dining on Pine Ave and about a five-minute walk to the beautiful beaches of the Gulf of Mexico. Come Relax and Unwind at this tastefully updated and turnkey furnished property that features 3 bedrooms and 3 baths. The property has been updated with a new metal roof, new paint inside and out, new stainless-steel appliances, exterior custom wood shutters, new landscaping and sprinkler system just too many items to list. Enjoy beach tranquility and the ultimate privacy from the very large yard located directly on Lake Marsha. There is plenty of room to install an oasis pool or leave it as it is for the nature-lover. The back yard has plenty of room to enjoy fishing, BBQing, sunbathing, kayaking, or just relaxing by the wood burning firepit. *Property information received from third-party sources is considered reliable but is not guaranteed. All information should be independently verified by buyers and buyer's agent.

105 Los Cedros Drive, Anna Maria

$15,995,000
4 Beds 6.5 Baths Shore Acres SubDv.
Completely renovated home on over 2 and a half acres directly on the Gulf of Mexico! Discover the epitome of privacy and seclusion at Anna Maria Island's Bean Point, where the tranquil waters of Tampa Bay flow into the Gulf of Mexico. Situated on the island's most coveted northern end, this coastal haven offers unmatched privacy and opulence. A 400-foot tree-lined driveway leads to a home highlighted by an impressive waterfall entrance, welcoming you to an environment of light and tranquility. Inside, you are greeted with sweeping 270-degree views that capture the essence of Gulf-front living. The chef's kitchen and incredible amenities ensure every convenience is at your fingertips, while a dedicated gym and sauna allow for health and relaxation. Expansive living areas flow seamlessly to the outdoor terraces, promoting a luxurious indoor-outdoor lifestyle. The home's crowning jewel, a secluded top-floor owner's suite, offers a peaceful retreat as well as an elevated pool deck. The easy-to-maintain grounds encourage relaxation under the Florida sun. Strategic property placement and protective regulations guarantee your Gulf views remain pristine and undisturbed. The estate also offers potential for customization with space to introduce a guest or pool house, enhancing its allure. Nestled within Anna Maria Island, renowned for its pristine beaches and Old-Florida charm, this property stands as a testament to beachfront luxury and seclusion. Embrace this rare opportunity to own a distinguished piece of paradise, embodying the quintessential Anna Maria lifestyle of luxury, privacy, and tranquil beauty. Completely renovated in 2023.

811 N Shore Drive, Anna Maria

$5,695,000
4 Beds 4.5 Baths Anna Maria Beach SubDv.
Under Construction. Welcome to 118 Mangrove Ave, a slice of tropical paradise nestled in the heart of Anna Maria, Florida. Scheduled to be completed in June, this 4 bedroom, 4.5 bath home will offer an unparalleled combination of luxury, comfort, and convenience. Turnkey furnished and thoughtfully appointed; this home is ready to fulfill your every desire. Vaulted ceilings and an abundance of natural light create an airy ambiance throughout the spacious floor plan. Each bedroom is a luxurious en-suite sanctuary, providing privacy and comfort for all. Gather in the expansive great room, where custom artwork accents the walls and sets the stage for memorable moments with loved ones. The gourmet kitchen will feature high-end stainless-steel appliances and offers the perfect blend of style and functionality for culinary enthusiasts. An elevator awaits to bring you effortlessly between floors of this exquisite retreat. As you move outside, you will step into your own private oasis, where a lush tropical landscape adorned with vibrant foliage and enchanting landscape lighting surrounds an oversized swimming pool and spa. Whether you're unwinding with a refreshing dip or hosting unforgettable poolside gatherings, this outdoor haven sets the stage for endless enjoyment. You can also indulge your inner golfer on your very own putting green or savor the flavors of outdoor cooking in the summer kitchen, where culinary adventures await. With every detail meticulously crafted for relaxation and entertainment, this residence epitomizes the quintessential Florida lifestyle. One of the most unique features are the breathtaking views from the oversized rooftop deck, that offer panoramic vistas of both the gulf and bay. Perfect for soaking in stunning sunsets or stargazing under the night sky, this elevated retreat is a true gem. Conveniently located within walking distance to shops, restaurants, and the charming trolley, this property will offer the best of both worlds: tranquility and accessibility. Whether you're seeking relaxation or adventure, 118 Mangrove Ave invites you to experience the ultimate in coastal living. Don't miss your opportunity to call this coastal retreat your own – schedule your private showing today and embark on a journey to luxury living in Anna Maria, Florida.

118 Mangrove Avenue, Anna Maria

$2,900,000
5 Beds 4 Baths Anna Maria Beach SubDv.
This fantastic three-level vacation home offers a private backyard featuring a pool, vibrant Adirondack seating, and a ping pong and foosball table! Located in one of the most prestigious areas on Anna Maria Island, this home is within walking distance of Pine Avenue with its adorable shops, wonderful restaurants, and the famous Anna Maria Pier. It is only a 5 minute walk to the Bayside and the Gulf side beach. This spacious home sleeps 14!! (Bert Harris approved property) Perfect for family and friend’s getaway, Lighthouse Lagoon offers an expansive living area with a large sectional and TV, and the kitchen has every appliance and dishware to prepare delicious homemade meals. There is island seating, a chic dining table, plush seating on the main-floor balcony, and a dining table for dining al fresco. Upstairs is an additional living space with a sofa, side chairs, a TV, and a second screened-in balcony! The primary bedroom is a coastal paradise with a fantastic ensuite bathroom with a double vanity, a walk-in shower, and a soaking tub, and this room has access to the second-floor balcony. On each living floor is a King bedroom and a Bunk bedroom. The first-floor King bedroom has an ensuite bathroom with a walk-in shower, and on each floor is a hall bathroom with a shower and tub combination. Additionally, there is a Queen sleeper sofa and a Twin sleeper sofa. Room Details -Primary Bedroom, 2nd floor: King bed, balcony access, and ensuite bathroom with soaking tub and walk-in shower -Second Bedroom, 1st floor: King bed and ensuite bathroom with walk-in shower -Third Bedroom, 2nd floor: King Bed -Fourth Bedroom, 2nd floor: Twin Bunk bed and Twin bed -Fifth Bedroom, 1st floor: Twin Bunk bed and Twin bed -Living Area: One Queen and One Twin Sleeper Sofa The backyard is beautifully landscaped with coconut palms and native species. The heated lagoon pool has a built-in dining table, and there are plenty of Adirondack chairs and a BBQ grill on the pool deck. Adjacent to the pool area is a recreation room with a Flat Panel LED TV, Foosball Table, Ping Pong Table, and a comfortable large sitting area. This home is equipped with wireless Internet, a XBOX gaming system, and assorted beach items. Highlights • Private Pool • 10-minute walk to the beach • Ping Pong Table and Foosball table • Near AMI City Pier, Pine Ave, and Bayfront Park • Dog Friendly

508 Spring Avenue, Anna Maria

$6,995,000
6 Beds 6.5 Baths Bimini Bay Estates SubDv.
Welcome to Sail Away, a captivating retreat nestled on a picturesque cul-de-sac in the premier location of Anna Maria Island. This south facing stunning 6-bedroom, 6.5-bathroom home offers a perfect blend of coastal charm, modern elegance, high-end features, and breathtaking views. Step into luxury as you enter this home and experience the seamless integration of indoor and outdoor living spaces. The bright and airy living room welcomes you with large windows that bathe the space in natural light, while the limitless wrap-around balconies provide panoramic views. Inside, you'll find an interior adorned with high-end finishes, tasteful modern decor, a soothing color palette, a state-of-the-art control 4 system with Lutron lighting, and a camera security system. The gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring top-of-the-line stainless steel appliances, custom cabinetry, and a massive island with a 6-burner gas range. The living room even boasts a beautiful custom glass wine cellar built into the wall, adding an exquisite touch to the space. The main floor of the home offers four generously sized bedrooms, each with its own bathroom, including a unique kids' built-in bunk bed room. On the upper level, you'll find the master bedroom ensuite, offering a spa-like atmosphere with a lavish soaking tub, walk-in shower, and dual vanities. There is also another master bedroom ensuite and a lounge area with a pool table, as well as sliding glass doors that lead to balcony access and a rooftop deck. The backyard oasis is the crowning jewel of this property. The expansive patio provides an idyllic setting for outdoor dining, sunbathing, or simply enjoying the natural beauty of the canals. Watch as manatees and dolphins pass by, or take a leisurely stroll on paddleboards or kayaks. The well designed dock is equipped with water and electric connections, a filet table, dock lighting, and a dual waverunner platform lift. And for ultimate relaxation, take a dip in the sparkling heated pool with a swim-up bar, and the covered spa surrounded by lush tropical landscaping and a sunken lounge area with a fireplace. With multiple balconies, a game room complete with foosball and ping pong tables, and a short 5-minute walk to the gorgeous sandy beaches and breathtaking sunsets of the Gulf of Mexico, this home offers a luxurious beachfront lifestyle like no other. It's also an exceptional investment opportunity, with over $270k in rental income last year and already over $208k so far this year. Additional features include an elevator servicing all floors for convenience, an oversized 3-car garage with built-in custom cabinets, epoxy floor coating, a workstation, and ample storage for beach toys and a golf cart. Schedule your private tour today and immerse yourself in the luxurious ambiance of Sail Away. Don't miss this opportunity to own a piece of paradise.

241 Willow Avenue, Anna Maria

$2,895,000
5 Beds 3 Baths Anna Maria Beach SubDv.
This exquisite turnkey furnished residence offers a ready-made vacation retreat in the heart of Anna Maria Island. Situated just a block away from the vibrant Pine Avenue, this coastal-inspired property encompasses a main house boasting 3 bedrooms and 2 baths, complemented by a charming guest cottage featuring 2 bedrooms and 1 bath. Built in 2015, the home epitomizes modern comfort and style, with tasteful decor throughout. Step inside to discover a spacious gourmet kitchen seamlessly flowing into the inviting living areas, perfect for hosting gatherings and creating lasting memories. Beyond the interiors, the outdoor living space beckons, featuring a private heated pool with cocktail table and sun shelf all situated between the main house and guest cottage, providing an idyllic setting for relaxation and entertainment amidst the island's tropical ambiance. The unique layout of the home is perfect for a multitude of uses, offering separate spaces for privacy and togetherness. Enjoy the convenience of a 1-car garage, providing ample storage space for a vehicle and beach essentials. Conveniently located within walking distance to both Gulf and Bay beaches, as well as a myriad of dining and shopping options along Pine Avenue, Jersey Girl offers unparalleled access to Anna Maria's coveted amenities. Short-term rentals are allowed, adding to the versatility and investment potential of this remarkable property. With a Bert Harris Exemption, this property is approved to sleep 12 people per Anna Maria City code, presenting an exceptional investment opportunity. Whether you're seeking a primary residence, a second home, or a lucrative vacation rental, Jersey Girl offers versatile possibilities. Make Jersey Girl your own slice of coastal paradise.

423 Spring Avenue, Anna Maria

$4,500,000
5 Beds 5 Baths Wells Bay Harbor SubDv.
Discover your own piece of PARADISE on Anna Maria Island's North end with this stunning Custom Elevated-Built WATERFRONT home. Perfectly situated for easy access to Anna Maria Pier, pristine beaches, waterfront dining, and Pine Avenue's shopping delights, this home offers unparalleled convenience and BREATHTAKING VIEWS! Indulge in culinary delights in the gourmet kitchen featuring two expansive islands, amazing quartz countertops, and top-of-the-line appliances. With five spacious bedrooms, including 4 with private bathrooms, multiple living areas, and a bonus loft, this home offers ample space for RELAXATION and entertaining. Dive into LUXURY with a heated saltwater pool and enjoy boating adventures with the boat dock and lift on the canal. Eco-friendly features such as a rainwater cistern system and energy-efficient elements ensure sustainable living. Additional perks include an elevator servicing all floors, and dual garages with storage. With over $100k in vacation rental income and potential to exceed $200k annually, this turn-key ready home offers both a LUXURIOUS LIFESTYLE and investment opportunity. All furnishings are included, making it truly turnkey. This home, with a grandfathered clause allowing accommodation for up to 12 people instead of the current 8 person max capacity, presents an ideal VACATION GETAWAY with substantial rental income potential. Escape to WATERFRONT LIVING at its finest – schedule your private viewing today!

505 S Bay Boulevard, Anna Maria

Start Your Search